1. Rang De Basanti (2006): In every sense of the word Rang De Basanti is a winner. Its aesthetic values and characterizations fill you with amazement and elation. It’s a gloriously triumphant look at today’s lives. And yet it audaciously takes a sweeping arching look at history for answers to the Big Question.Where has today’s generation gone wrong? Why is the nation so inured in corruption? And why are we so enamoured of the stagnant status quo?Are we scared to sweep the garbage? Lofty thoughts , often swept by popular art under a carpet of cynicism. Not this time! Rakeysh Mehra achieves a stirring and stunning synthesis of social relevance and mesmeric storytelling. From the start we are led into a world where youthful aspirations are aligned to the socio-political reality of a country on the brink. Rang De Basanti is a film on the edge. It jumps and careens across lives prancing on the precipice of the contemporary and the historical. “Is desh ka kuch nahin hoga!” How many times have we said this to ourselves and to others Mehra’s protagonists , an assorted bunch of collegians and post-college friends, are played with amazingly casual grace by Aamir Khan(DJ) , Siddharth(Karan) , Sharman Joshi(Sukhi), Kunal Kapoor (Aslam) and Soha Ali Khan(Sonia). Into their world of endless fun and aimless aspirations comes a pretty and brainy British girl named Sue(the lovely and graceful debutant Alice Patten). Prompted by her colonist-grandfather’s diary, Sue wants to make a film on the life of the legendary Indian freedom fighters—you know, Bhagat Singh, Chandrashekhar Azad, the works.And guess what? Sue wants to cast DJ and gang as the revolutionaries! The guffaws and the giggles that follow Sue’s dreams fade away, as this youthful brigade of adrift dreamers gets down to the ritual of acquainting itself with Indian history.Rang De Basanti dares to point fingers , and tells us where we’ve gone wrong. It isn’t only a film about the education of a moorless generation, it’s also an outstandingly accomplished piece of cinema. Mehra proves himself an outstanding racounteur and technician. With the deft and diligent editor(P.S Bharathi) tailoring the past to merge fluently into the present, and Binod Pradhan’s camera capturing Delhi and its surroundings as a character rather than cities , Mehra’s job of bringing the past into the same line of vision as contemporary India , is rendered inevitable and unforgettable.Rang De Basanti is an extremely ambitions film. It tries to educate the generationsIndependent India who have brought the country to its current crisis of moral and political corruption. But it never gets hysterical or polemical, thanks to Prasoon Joshi and Rensil D Silva’s conversational yet penetrating dialogues. Mani Rathnam attempted the same theme in a different less dramatic light in Yuva. Rakeysh Mehra goes many steps ahead. He blends historical events from the past (e.g the massacre by Britishers at Jallianwala Bagh) with today’s newspaper headlines(the MIG war- planes scam) . The film-within-a-film format(earlier attempted in films as diverse in language and intent as Karel Reisez’s The French Lieutenant’s Woman and Mrinal Sen’s Akaler Sandhane) gives the narrative the texture of a life lived in layered luminosity.Not for a second does Rakeysh Mehra falter in his vision. The story of today’s youth , their lack of connectivity with their past , and the prevalent moral degeneration pf the nation , could quite easily have lapsed into a holier-than-thou jingoistc exposition. Rang De Basanti works wonderfully and exceptionally as both a political parable and a spanking story on the scars of the times. In the fusion of fact and fiction, style and content the film is both teasing and tempting . While you applaud the filmmaker’s immense stronghold over his storytelling the characters never seem dwarfed by their ambience.You come away , haunted and bewildered by the issues that Mehra raises without letting his story suffer in the process of linking the modern tale with history. You come away from Rang De Basanti enchanted by the natural verve of its songs and dances, its director’s flair creating fissures and feeling from within the characters rather than imposing creative authority from outside. There’re interludes and visuals in Rang De Basanti which shall remain alive forever. There may be better films . But there will never be another one quite like this one.
2. Lage Raho Munnabhai(2006): It’s all a “chemical locha”(aberration). Munnabhai meets Mahatma Gandhi and they get along like a house on fire . The prophetic leader from the past has a blast as he tells Munna how to deal with an avaricious builder(Boman Irani) and other ouch-casts of society. It looks like Circuit has competition this time. Even as he remains a fiercely loyal Hanuman to his mentor Munna, Munna this time shifts his loyalties and attention to the lovely RJ Jahanvi and to Mahatma Gandhi who keeps appearing in Munna’s day-time reverie to advise the benign gangster on love life and other vagaries of being human. Munna and Circuit, arguably cinema’s most adorable and roguish reformists since Laurel and Hardy go about the business of generating humour out of the pathos of the human condition. The sequences, all fiercely and famously path-breaking have us in splits.Watch the love-lorn Munnabhai answer a Gandhian quiz on a phone-in radio quiz with the help of kidnapped professors…it’s one of the most comically animated sequences seen in the movies of the new millennium.To look at Lage Raho Munnabhai as a ‘serious comedy’ is to seriously undermine the motivations and impact of the series(and let’s face it, there’s no getting away from the Munna-Circuit jodi for the producer and director).Playing the sweat-smart ruffians with hearts of cool, Sanjay Dutt and Arshad Warsi bring a chirpy enchantment to their roles. Their parts have hefty hearts. But there’s more. There’s an innocence and a desire to make the world a better place.The Munna-Mahatma dialogues sparkle with satirical wisdom, thanks in no small part to Dutt and Dilip Prabhavalkar(who plays Gandhiji with tongue-in-cheek conviction). The dialogues by Hirani and Abhijeet Joshi constantly probe the festering moral and social system of the nation without getting hysterical on homilies. The individual scenes make light of national issues without ever trivializing the cult of the conscience.At heart—and boy, does this film have it in plenty!—Lage Raho Munnabhai is a parable on love and companionship. Whether it’s Munnabhai’s bonding with his faithful companion Circuit(watch the two actors turn that potentially mawkish sequence at the dockyard into something special) or Munna courting love(Balan) and Gandhism, the narrative dodges false notes by remaining sincere to the characters Every actor gets a chance to special in this enriching take of non-violent protest and radio-activity . But Dutt and Warsi go beyond. Sanjay Dutt proves again that he has shaped up into a fine performer who can mingle poignancy with satire the way Raj Kapoor did in those parables to innocence like Shri 420 and Awara , or like Sunil Dutt did in Milan and Meherbaan.
Warsi manages to steal some scenes from Dutt. Vidya Balan is gloriously glamorous and likeable, though she could’ve toned down those expressions of coy contemporaneity that make her look like a model for cornflakes.
In fact some of the emotional moments like those between Jimmy Shergil and his screen-father Pariskshat Sahni or that flamboyant wedding finale where the bride Diya Mirza tells the truth about her horoscope at the cost of turning her groom away, do not have the emotional impact which one thought they would.
Though a wee short of tears, Lage Raho Munnabhai goes a long way in creating an enduring and endearing parable on the importance of being earnest in a world of growing duplicity.
The narrative is so unfailingly heartwarming and the characters so full of human kindness, you wait for the plot to be weighed down by excessive self-importance.
The fall never happens. Lage Raho Munnabhai remains true to its characters till the end.
One of Munna’s favourite words is ‘daring’.
It must also be Raj Kumar Hirani’s favourite word. In a world of extravagant cynicism and rancour he dares to dream of Gandhian peace.
When the aggressive Munna turns his other cheek , you wonder if Gandhian values have a place in our heart.They most certainly do have a place in Hirani’s art. Shall we take it up from there?
