Chris Evans, unlike his squeaky-clean, alter ego Captain America, isn’t afraid to have a good time. Given this, it’s no surprise that the 39-year-old actor has been romantically linked to several of Hollywood’s biggest names. He most recently sparked romance rumours with Mamma Mia! Here We Go Again actress Lily James when the two were seen enjoying an ice cream date in London. Take a look at every woman alleged to have dated Chris below, whether the relationships were real (ex: Jessica Biel) or simply rumoured (ex: Kate Bosworth?!).

1. Kate Bosworth

After encountering on the set of their drama The Newcomers in 2000, Chris and Kate Bosworth were romantically connected.

2. Jessica Beil

Jessica Biel began dating Chris in 2001, and the two remained together as romantic interests in the films Cellular and London.

In 2006, they called it quits, and Jessica went on to marry Justin Timberlake.

3. Emmy Rossum

Chris met actress Emmy Rossum in early 2007 and was caught making out with her in March at a Hollywood pub called Teddy’s.

Regardless, Emmy’s representative stated that the two were “simply friends.”

4. Christina Ricci

No one knows how long Chris dated Christina Ricci, but the two were seen strolling the red carpet together at the 2007 Met Gala.

<5. Vida Guerra

In 2008, the then-26-year-old Fantastic Four actor was seen out and about in Los Angeles with Cuban model Vida Guerra, prompting speculation that she’d officially stolen Chris’s heart (which she hadn’t).

6. Kristin Cavallari

Chris and Kristin “certainly hooked up” at the launch of Cabana One at the Mayfair Hotel in Miami in October 2008, according to the New York Post, but Kristin personally told everyone that they were just good friends.

7. Amy Smart

Amy Smart was spotted leaving a London nightclub with Chris in August 2010, but her rep denied the two were dating.

8. Dianna Agron

Following her breakup from actor Alex Pettyfer, Dianna Agron supposedly met Chris at a pre-Oscars party in April 2011 and the two briefly dated.

9. Ashley Greene 

Twilight actress Ashley Greene was spotted “all over” Chris at Hollywood hotspot Trousdale in March 2011.

10. Sandra Bullock

Chris has never tried to disguise the fact that Sandra Bullock was his boyhood crush, so when the two were photographed cuddling and posing together at a Vanity Fair party in 2012, it was adorable.

Chris and Sandra were spotted out to dinner several times in 2014 with friends Chelsea Handler and Melissa McCarthy, with a source telling ENews, “They haven’t put a title on it, but they like each other.”

11. Lily Collins

After meeting at an Oscars afterparty in early 2015, Chris and Lily Collins sparked dating rumours.

When they were seen sharing a romantic dinner at an Italian restaurant in Los Angeles in March of that year, it appeared that their romance was on the up and up, but things appear to have fizzled.

12. Minka Kelly

Chris had an on-again, off-again romance with Friday Night Lights actress Minka Kelly for quite some time. The couple began dating in 2007, broke up in 2008, reconnected in 2012, and then broke up again in 2013.

When Minka was sighted visiting Chris’s house in October 2014 and when they took a lovely stroll together over Labor Day weekend in September 2015, the rumour mill went into overdrive again, but they never confirmed anything.